Critic’s Rating: ★★★½☆ (3.5/5)
Director: Scott Beck, Bryan Wood
Cast: Hugh Grant, Sophie Thatcher, Chloe East
Plot
Heretic Movie Review follows Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), two young missionaries from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, on their journey to convert souls. Their seemingly routine visit to Mr. Reed’s (Hugh Grant) remote home takes a sinister turn as the charming host reveals his darker intentions. What begins as a philosophical debate on religion quickly devolves into a battle for survival, forcing the girls to confront both their beliefs and the horrifying truth about their host.
What Works
The film’s success hinges on its stellar casting. Hugh Grant’s portrayal of Mr. Reed is nothing short of mesmerizing. He transitions seamlessly from a genial, grandfatherly figure to a menacing manipulator, keeping viewers on edge throughout. His signature charm adds layers to the character, making his descent into sinister territory even more unsettling.
Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East deliver grounded, compelling performances as Sister Barnes and Sister Paxton. Thatcher shines as the pragmatic, street-smart Barnes, while East evolves from timid and naïve to bold and defiant, with the duo’s chemistry driving the film’s emotional core.
The film’s minimalist approach, focusing on just three characters, works in its favor. The tension-filled confrontations between the missionaries and Mr. Reed keep the narrative taut, with sharp dialogue and well-executed twists sustaining the suspense.
What Doesn’t Work
While Heretic offers moments of intellectual intrigue, its exploration of religion and theology feels shallow, serving more as a backdrop than a fully developed theme. The film also struggles with pacing at times, with certain scenes feeling overly drawn-out, diluting the tension.
Fashion and Style in Heretic
The costume design subtly complements the film’s themes. The missionaries wear modest, traditional outfits that reflect their faith and innocence, creating a stark contrast to the eerie, homely setting of Mr. Reed’s house. Reed’s attire—a cozy cardigan and slacks—masks his sinister nature, reinforcing the deceptive charm that makes him such a compelling antagonist.
The muted color palette of the costumes mirrors the film’s overall aesthetic, enhancing the ominous atmosphere and adding to the sense of unease.
Read Also : Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3 Review: A Middling Horror-Comedy with a Few Laughs
Stree 2 Movie Review: A Headless Delight with Humor and Spooks
Final Verdict
Heretic is a gripping psychological horror that thrives on its performances and tightly woven tension. Hugh Grant’s chilling turn as the enigmatic Mr. Reed and the strong chemistry between Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East elevate the film beyond its narrative shortcomings. While it doesn’t delve deeply into its theological themes, it remains a thrilling exploration of belief, manipulation, and survival.
